Cricut Vinyl Cutters: Joy, Explore or Maker?

High score Our score: 9.6/10

Cricut

Cricut Joy 2 Essential Bundle + Rainbow Sampler

9.6/10Our score, based on listed specifications and buyer feedback

See it on Amazon

Price and specifications are read from the Amazon product page and can change.

Cricut Joy 2 Essential Bundle

Best for: Quick cards, decals and labels

Pros

• Ultra-compact, just over 2 lbs
• Print-then-cut stickers
• Rainbow materials included
• Bluetooth to Design Space

Cons

• 75+ materials, fewest here
• Suited to small projects

The Cricut Joy 2 Essential Bundle pairs Cricut’s newest ultra-compact machine with a Rainbow Sampler of materials. The listing says the Joy 2 is 4.5 inches (a small footprint) and weighs just over 2 lbs, which makes it easy to keep on a shelf and pull out when needed. It is aimed at quick, everyday projects like custom cards, simple decals and labels.

Cricut Joy 2 works with 75+ materials, including vinyl, iron-on, printable materials and cardstock, and it writes, draws, foils, scores and cuts. It also works with your home inkjet printer: you print a design, and the machine recognizes it and cuts around it, which is how you make full-color stickers. This is called Print-Then-Cut. It connects by Bluetooth to Design Space, Cricut’s free app, which has step-by-step design flows and templates. The bundle adds Smart Vinyl, Smart Iron-On, Value Cardstock, Insert Card Sets and Printable Vinyl. Smart materials are Cricut products you can load without a cutting mat. There is a 1 year limited warranty on the machine.

Choose this for a beginner who mostly wants labels, cards and small decals. It gives way to the Explore 5 or Maker 4 if you plan larger shirts, signs or thicker materials.

High score Our score: 9.6/10

Cricut

Cricut Maker 4 Cutting Machine Ultimate Beginner Sticker Making Bundle – Print Then Cut Machine with Waterproof Sticker Paper & Vinyl for Custom Stickers & Small Business, Seashell Die-Cutting Machine

9.6/10Our score, based on listed specifications and buyer feedback

See it on Amazon

Price and specifications are read from the Amazon product page and can change.

Cricut Maker 4 Cutting Machine Ultimate

Best for: Sticker sellers and small businesses

Pros

• Sticker paper and vinyl included
• Print Then Cut
• Mat-free cuts up to 12 ft

Cons

• Bundle contents loosely described
• Select tools sold separately

Best for: Crafters wanting every material and tool

Pros

• 300+ materials
• Engraves, debosses, perforates
• Full tool kit included
• Up to 2X faster than predecessor

Cons

• Some tools sold separately
• Full library needs paid subscription

The Cricut Maker 4 Engagement Bundle in Seashell is Cricut’s top machine. The listing says it works with 300+ materials, including leather, wood, vinyl, iron-on HTV (heat transfer vinyl, the kind you iron onto fabric), cardstock and stickers. Beyond cutting, it draws, foils, scores, engraves, debosses and perforates, and the description says it cuts up to 2X faster than the previous model.

This bundle is generous: Maker 4, a Fine-Point Blade, Light Grip Mat, 2 fine point pens, mini weeder, practice cut materials, scoring stylus, scraper, spatula, weeder, Smart Iron-On, Smart Vinyl, a cardstock sampler, transfer tape and 30 digital images. A weeder is a small hooked tool for picking away the vinyl you do not want after cutting. It supports Print-Then-Cut with most inkjet printers. Design Space is free, but the full library of 1.5 million+ images and fonts requires the optional paid Cricut Access subscription.

Pick this for an ambitious crafter who wants to grow into leather, wood and engraving. For those who mostly want sticker production, the next bundle is built around that.

The Cricut Maker 4 Cutting Machine Ultimate Beginner Sticker Making Bundle uses the same Seashell Maker 4 but builds the kit around stickers. It includes printable sticker paper described as waterproof, adhesive vinyl, tools and project guidance, and the listing aims it at Etsy sellers and small businesses making stickers, labels and packaging.

The description repeats the Maker 4 strengths: 300+ materials, 13 compatible tools (select tools sold separately), and Smart Materials that cut continuously up to 12 ft without a mat. Print Then Cut with your inkjet printer turns printed designs into cut stickers. The listing does not give an exact item-by-item list of the materials and tools, and its model number differs from the Engagement Bundle’s, so check the contents if specific items matter. It lists a 1 year warranty against manufacturer defects.

This suits someone starting a side business or making stickers in volume. If you want the classic tool kit and wider material sampler, the Engagement Bundle above is the better fit. For more about printing-focused setups, see our Cricut printer machine guide.

Best for: Beginners wanting a mid-size vinyl kit

Pros

• Mat, sampler, tape and tools
• Print-Then-Cut
• 50+ materials

Cons

• Mat grip type listed inconsistently
• Fewer materials than Explore or Maker

Cricut

Cricut Joy Xtra Cutting Machine and Smart Vinyl Bundle for Labels, Decals & Custom Projects – Includes Rainbow Permanent Vinyl, Transfer Tape, Tools & Design Guides

8.6/10Our score, based on listed specifications and buyer feedback

See it on Amazon

Price and specifications are read from the Amazon product page and can change.

Cricut Joy Xtra Cutting Machine

Best for: Teachers and home organizers making labels

Pros

• Rainbow permanent vinyl
• Smart Vinyl cuts without a mat
• Compact 12.5 in wide

Cons

• Few specs in listing
• Warranty not listed

The Cricut Joy Xtra Cutting Machine and Smart Vinyl Bundle is focused on vinyl. It includes the Joy Xtra, rainbow permanent Smart Vinyl, transfer tape, essential tools and digital design guides. Permanent vinyl is the long-lasting kind for water bottles and storage bins, while transfer tape is the sticky sheet that lifts your cut design and places it on the surface.

The listing says compatible Smart Vinyl loads directly without a mat for faster setup and longer continuous cuts. It measures 5.5 inches deep by 12.5 inches wide and 5.5 inches tall, with an active surface area of 68.75 square inches. Beyond that, the listing is thin: it does not state a material count, Print-Then-Cut support or warranty, although the other Joy Xtra listing below does mention Print-Then-Cut.

This bundle suits teachers labeling a classroom, parents organizing a pantry and anyone who mainly wants colorful vinyl projects. It gives way to the Vinyl Starter Kit if you want a mat included for non-Smart materials.

The Cricut Joy Xtra Smart Cutting Machine Vinyl Starter Kit includes the machine, a machine mat, a Smart Vinyl sampler pack, one 9.5 in x 20 ft roll of transfer tape and a 5-piece tool set. The listing says Joy Xtra works with 50+ materials, including vinyl, iron-on HTV, cardstock and stickers, and it cuts, writes, draws and foils. Print-Then-Cut with most inkjet printers is supported.

One inconsistency: the bundle list names a StandardGrip mat, while a later feature line mentions a Strong Grip mat. The listing does not clarify which one ships. A cutting mat is a sticky sheet that holds non-Smart materials in place during cutting. There is a 1-year manufacturer warranty.

This is a well-rounded starter kit for a new crafter who wants mid-size projects without the bulk of a larger machine. It gives way to the Explore 5 bundle for more materials.

Best for: First-timers wanting room to grow

Pros

• 100+ materials
• Vinyl, HTV, cardstock included
• Bluetooth setup
• 100+ project eBook

Cons

• Fewer materials than Maker 4

The Cricut Explore 5 Essential Bundle sits in the middle of the lineup. The listing says the Explore 5 cuts 100+ materials, including vinyl, HTV, cardstock, printable materials, paper and felt. The bundle includes Smart Vinyl, Smart Iron-On, printable vinyl, cardstock, insert cards and a 100+ project eBook.

Setup uses Bluetooth and Design Space with guided tutorials and templates, and the listing calls it ideal for first-time users, hobby crafters, teachers and small business owners making decals, shirts, tote bags and wedding projects. It carries a 1 year limited warranty. The listing does not mention engraving or debossing, which are Maker 4 features. If you want a broader look at the brand’s machines, our Cricut craft machine guide goes further.

This is the sweet spot for a beginner who expects to do more than labels. It gives way to the Maker 4 for leather, wood and engraving.